Minister of National Revenue v. Harry Bronfman, Samuel Bronfman, Abe Bronfman and Barnett Aaron, [1965] CTC 386, 65 DTC 5239

By services, 11 April, 2023
Is tax content
Tax Content (confirmed)
Citation
Citation name
[1965] CTC 386
Citation name
65 DTC 5239
Decision date
d7 import status
Drupal 7 entity type
Node
Drupal 7 entity ID
675903
Extra import data
{
"field_court_parentheses": "",
"field_external_guid": [],
"field_full_style_of_cause": "MINISTER OF NATIONAL REVENUE, Appellant, and HARRY BRONFMAN, SAMUEL BRONFMAN, ABE BRONFMAN and BARNETT AARON, Respondents.",
"field_import_body_hash": "",
"field_informal_procedure": false,
"field_year_parentheses": "",
"field_source_url": ""
}
Style of cause
Minister of National Revenue v. Harry Bronfman, Samuel Bronfman, Abe Bronfman and Barnett Aaron
Main text

DUMOULIN, J.:—At the start of trial, the parties hereto moved that appeal number 145-751 of this Court’s records, between The Minister of National Revenue, appellant, and Allan Bronfman, respondent, serve mutatis mutandis as a pattern decision for the instant cases, both as to the facts and the pertinent law.

Therefore, these appeals are allowed as follows: the respondents will be assessed for a portion of the income tax attaching to the $97,000 donated, rateably to the number of shares owned, during the material years, of the total capital stock of Brintcan Holdings (Canada) Limited.

The records of the cases will be referred to the Minister for revision accordingly.

These appeals succeeding but partially, no costs are granted to either party.